I don’t shop at target: Thoughts from an ex-secularist apologist (Response to “I Shop at Target: thoughts from a Preacher’s Wife”)

Preface

Recently an article was passed around my Christian friends with some excitement. I believe this article was dangerously misguiding (beyond this particular Target issue) and therefore in need of address. Generally, I agree with Cheree that we need a new strategy. I hope that is why this article became popular. However, the particular solutions within the article need to be addressed, lest the seeds grow into something more substantial. As usual here are a few preface points before I begin my response:

  1. I am not taking a stance on the actual bathroom issue here – just addressing the fallacies in the article. As for the title, I have never really shopped at Target because I find it overpriced, so this new issue isn’t something I really have to lose sleep over. Personally, I have always thought of Target as a place for people who are willing to pay an extra 40% to stay away from the “people of Walmart.” (I’m half joking here)
  2. This really is about the bigger picture and the various ideological responses from Christians. (I have attached several other articles below. They do a much better job of explaining my perspectives on boycotting in general).
  3. I have love for Cheree as a sister in Christ, but I really don’t agree with what she has said. In fact I think the ideas are harmful, but if this should make its way back to Cheree or her friends, please don’t take this as a personal attack.
  4. I have presented this in a conversation format to make things easier to follow and keep word count down. (Here is the original article: http://sisterpastorcheree.blogspot.com/2016/04/i-shop-at-target-thoughts-from.html)
Body

Statement: I shop at Target. I like TargetMy family looks like a walking Target ad.

Response: Then that is precisely what you are… a Target ad. (See: SOCIAL FOOTPRINT: 5 WAYS YOU ARE SECRETLY SUPPORTING BUSINESS MISSIONS). Just make sure that you are comfortable advertising for them. That’s up to you.

____

Statement: “Wow. This didn’t come from a pulpit or “preacher post.” Nope. It came from secular media.”

Response: Eric Metaxas is, for lack of an easily definable term, a conservative Christian apologist. He is not a secular media writer. I agree that we should be thankful that such voices get a spotlight in a major secular publication. However, you are mistaken to think that this is not a “preacher post.” It just happens to be a last bastion of conservative Christianity – one that was likely relegated to some darkened corner of a generally liberalized secular newspaper. Woo-hoo? Also, it would be nice if more Christians were aware of men like Metaxas, but the sad truth is that most of us are more interested in self-help devotionals than deep studies of Scripture and apologetics.

____

Statement: “Why do we insist on cramming it down everyone’s throat – including one another’s – when we feel threatened?”

Response: Good point. We do have a problem with this. As to the why: Aside from our general sin, fear, and selfishness, one of the main reasons is laziness. It’s far easier to just tell people “thus saith my Bible” than to study why God may have said something and learn how to contextualize that message to those who do not take the Bible as authoritative. Ironically, this is the type of information that comes from apologists like Metaxas.

____

Statement: “I just think it’s time we change our perspective.

Response: I agree. I’m just not so sure that Cheree’s article has arrived at the best replacement.

____

Statement: “God’s ways are perfect. He causes ALL things to work for our good. His plans are flawless.”

Response:  Translation: “Because of God’s sovereignty, we can just trust that He has a plan.” While I ultimately agree about resting in God’s sovereignty, this statement is dangerous. It approaches some form of selective Hyper Calvinism, as if somehow trusting God relieves us of responsibility. To help my students grasp this concept, I tell them to look at an extreme. For example, if someone is about to run over your child, do you just sit back and say “Trust God’s plan?” I doubt it. This argument also fails philosophically in that the decision to write this paper takes action against a movement thus undermining the idea that we should just trust God’s plan.

____

Statement: “Half the people I see posting that they will NEVER shop at Target again either don’t have a Target in their town (so it doesn’t count) or are lying – not intentionally lying, but they’ll go back…you can’t stay away from that Target home section, those candles…admit it.”

Response: This is a particularly disturbing admission. Translation: “I care more about Target’s home section and candles than my values… and I know you do too.” That is indeed frightening. While I am sure this is true of many, it is scary to see people suggesting that this is acceptable and even presenting it as cute and playful like this is some kind of joke.

____

Statement: “Like, maybe instead of railing against our government for taking prayer and Bibles out of schools, we understand that there is NO PLACE ON EARTH that the Word of God cannot go.”

Response: Except those schools that just removed it (and the other places around the globe that it is increasingly becoming illegal or at least against policy to share Christianity.) 

____

Statement:  Teach your children the Word and it will go into their schools every day. It can’t be stopped.

Response: Except it is stopped- through policy, peer pressure, and indoctrination. More importantly, those children being sent into the public schools are being indoctrinated away from God’s word, resulting in a 70-90% dropout rate (depending on the study). With the rare exception, Christian students are not superheroes going into schools to save their peers. They are helpless lambs being led to the slaughter.

____

Statement: “The Holy Spirit walks into every Starbucks and Target I walk into…because He is alive in me. You want to make a difference? Go to your local Target today and while you’re shopping begin to meditate on the words of the Lord to Joshua – every place your feet step you will have authority.”

Response: So many problems here. 1) Hermeneutics 2) How many people are you really having encounters with at Target? I’m sure it happens once in a while for a handful of people, but while we’re on the topic of being real, let’s be honest… You are there for yourself. You are not there for them. Remember, it’s about the home section and candles… 3) You don’t have to spend money at Target to make a difference. Go window shop, pray over the place, tell people about Jesus, etc. But you don’t have to fund their agenda. You don’t have to spend money there to make a difference.  4) Even if you actually did lead someone to the Lord at a Target or wherever, how much funding have you just given to the mission, vision, and values of those companies in the process?

____

Statement: I won’t be using the restrooms (neither will my daughters) at ANY establishment that allows men in a ladies’ room. It’s not wise.

Response: Translation: This policy makes me so uncomfortable that my family will not use the restroom, but I sure love those candles… so we’ll just hold it.

Closing Thoughts

I am not just being a Negative Nancy. I agree that new solutions are needed. While I think the ideas of the original article were terribly misguided, I am working on a series of articles designed to help people (whatever their political persuasion) to rightly represent their values through their purchasing decisions. See Below:

 

1Comment
  • Tammy Watt
    Posted at 18:04h, 29 April Reply

    For the record I understand that not everyone sees the world as I do and that includes my brothers and sisters in Christ.

    I feel like I can’t help but respond and accept and take responsibility these are my views, but maybe some food for thought. I also want to acknowledge the authors statement that his article is not necessarily him taking a “stand” on the bathroom issue.

    For the record I do have a Target in my town and until recently shopped there and possessed a Target Charge card which for the record I paid off every month (just not wanting to debate to “debt” principles as interpreted by my fellow Christians.) While I agree that often Target’s prices are higher than Walmart in many cases their sales along with the discounts given for using my Red Zone card often beat the everyday prices of my local Walmart. In addition I have often found that specific items I wanted or needed were often found at Target with ease where often they would need to be ordered at other stores. . . I confess many times I found myself at Target to purchase these things because I procrastinated till the last minute. That being said, after Target announced their new policy on the Transgender bathroom as well as other issues I made a conscious decision that I did not want to support this business any longer and have cancelled my Target Card. I can honestly say I do not intend to ever do business with Target again. This not because I oppose the Gay, Lesbian, or Transgender person but rather the lifestyle I do not approve of.

    As a Female of both Native American and Cacusain decent who attended schools that were predominantly attended by African Americans, I have both seen discrimination and been a subject of it. It is my position that God created man in His image and that ALL of mankind are the children of God and that He loves us all, unfortunately some of us do not KNOW who our Father is. In other words God loves the person but hates the sin. Let me be clear here sin is sin and I have at many times in my life been guilty of it.

    What is sin though? Well, I would say that the definition of sin is to miss the “mark” when it comes to God’s plan for your life. God’s plan. . . I belive that was referenced above in the statement that “God has a plan and all things work together for good.” Which are indeed quotes from the Bible, in fact it’s Roman 8:28. But the rest of that scripture read “of those who love Him and are called to “His” purpose.” Which brings me to my point. . . Do I love Him and if so what is my purpose.?

    God created man and He gave us a Kingdom to rule and reign . . . He called it earth. Now here comes your food for thought. . . If the Earth is man’s kingdom to rule and reign than doesn’t it stand to reason that the person in charge of what happens on the earth is MAN not GOD! Now before you shut me out, hear me out. . . The thing that makes the earth special is that you have to have a specific thing to function on the earth. . . a body! God’s only ability and means to be able to function on earth is if He is invited to take up residence within man and even then His abilities are limited to what the man He resides in allows! I don’t know about you but willing to admit that I don’t always even now follow through with giving Him full control. . . I miss the mark sometimes and I’ve been a be beliver for 40ish years.

    Some sins are detailed out in the Word of God but many are not so what is a “sin” for me may not be a sin for you. I choose not to shop at Target not out of fear or hate of the Transgender person but rather because I do not agree with their overall policies and have felt a check in MY spirit that tells me I do not wish to use my money to support a company whos policies go againt my morals and/or beliefs, and to do so would cause me to “miss the mark” for me. If you feel differently then I wish you all the best. I am the Supreme being over my part of the earth and yes that includes every place I set my feet, but as for me and my feet. . . Well we won’t be giving money to Target, but that decision is based solely on what I believe I am supposed to do.

    One last comment. . . as a woman who has given birth to a daughter I totally understand the concerns of safety that are being brought out. . . But for the record this momma also birthed 2 sons one of which scores very high on the Autism spectrum. . . If I were to vocalize safety concerns they go both ways. . . Maybe even more towards the “female ” Transgender who are using the “male” restrooms. . . I don’t know about you but as a shopper it was more frequent that I alone would be shopping with my children and it is I alone who would be waiting for my “big” boys to exit the men’s room. . . But again, It’s the overall policies that disturb me and have lead me to a decision. I take ownership. . . I am a Christian who believes whole heartly in God’s Word but I refuse to hide my decisions behind a label of Christianity or fear. . . It’s what I believe serves my “purpose “

Leave a Reply

We only ship to the continental United States