Why Does God Allow Suffering?

*The following is adapted from the various chapters of Prove It: The Art & Science of Understanding & Articulating Why You Believe What You Believe

Why Does God Allow Suffering?

One of the emotionally strongest arguments against the existence of God is known as the Problem of Evil.  In fact, one of my students told me that it made an appearance in the latest Batman vs. Superman movie in the form of an atheistic apologetic. In short, the Problem of Evil concludes that an all loving God cannot exist when evil exists. This seems reasonable at first, at least on an emotional level. However, a closer look at the logic shows that the Problem of Evil is not a problem for theists, but it is a problem for atheists.

Here is one formal presentation of The Problem Of Evil.

1. A God that is all powerful would be able to prevent evil and suffering.

2. A God that is all knowing would know that evil and suffering happen.

3. A God that is all loving wouldn’t want evil and suffering to happen and would take needed action to stop it.

4. Evil and suffering happen.

Conclusion: Since evil and suffering exist, an all-powerful, all-knowing and all-loving God cannot exist.

*If each point is accurate, then the conclusion follows logically. Therefore, as a theist, we must determine if there are problems with any of the individual points(premises 1-4). If not, then God does not exist. Hint: There are several problems.

Addressing the Errors in This Syllogism
  1. Point one is correct
  2. Point two is correct
  3. Point three is speculative (We will address this below)
  4. Point four is only true if God exists and therefore becomes self refuting. In short, evil suggests right and wrong action/events, with evil being the wrong action or event. However, without God there is no evil, things simply are. Borrowing language from the famous skeptic David Hume, without God there only “is,” there is no “ought.” Now deceased atheist professor at Cornell, William Provine, said it well: “Let me summarize my views on what modern evolutionary biology tells us loud and clear, and I must say that these are basically Darwin’s views. There are no gods, no purposeful forces of any kind, no life after death. When I die, I am absolutely certain that I am going to be completely dead. That’s just all—that’s gonna be the end of me. There is no ultimate foundation for ethics, no ultimate meaning in life, and no free will for humans, either.” (To understand this better read: Can You Be Good Without God: 5 Reasons Moral Relativism Fail.)

So point four already shows us that the “Problem of Evil” is really no problem at all – at least not for theists. For atheists, however, evil is a problem. The only way to arrive at evil from atheism is to make vast assumptions that contradict the foundation of their worldview.

Premise 3

Premise three states that “A God that is all loving wouldn’t want evil and suffering to happen and would take needed action to stop it.” First of all, this assumes perfect knowledge. As the statement claims to know what an all-loving God would do, to make this claim one must know everything that an all-loving, all-knowing God would know. The moment someone introduces me to a person who has this level of knowledge, I will concede.

Second, premise three sets up somewhat of a false dichotomy (only two options, when there are at least three). The third option is that an all-knowing, all-loving God would allow evil to exist. Of course, premise three does hold certain emotional influence. It seems strange at first thought that a loving God would allow us to experience all the hardships that we experience. Therefore, it’s important for us to address why God might not stop suffering and evil from occurring.

5 Reasons Why God Allows Evil (What purpose does it serve?)

There is not one reason that God allows evil and suffering. There are many. Surely, this is not an exhaustive list, but here are five reasons that God says that He allows suffering. Comment below if you can think of any others. I may even use your ideas in my updated articles, videos, or books down the road!

  • Evil is necessary for choice (free will) to exist.

This is a bit complicated. Think about it this way, if God eliminated free will and everything was perfect, we would be nothing but robots. We not only wouldn’t make a mistake, we couldn’t make a mistake. Again, this is a very simple explanation of a complex philosophical idea, but you should be able to get the basic idea. Evil must exist if choice exists.

  • To Show Us That We Are But Beasts Without God

The wisdom literature of Ecclesiastes 3 tells us… “In the place of justice there is wickedness and in the place of righteousness there is wickedness… “God has surely tested them in order for them to see that they are but beasts (Ecclesiastes 3:16-18).”  By allowing us to make decisions, God is also showing us our sinful nature without Him. It is no surprise that as modern atheism has moved further and further away from God, we are increasingly placing value on the animalistic part of ourselves. This is precisely the pattern Paul describes in Romans 1.

  • Trials Test Worship

Job was a faithful man. However, Satan pointed out that it is easy to worship God when everything is going your way. When you are blessed it is easy to sing praises, but then it raises the question, is it God that is being worshiped or the blessing? By allowing for suffering, we have to make the choice to praise Him despite not getting our way. It forces us to love Him above our situation.

  • It Produces Good Fruit

The world says it this way, “What does kill you makes you stronger.” The Bible is a little more eloquent. “Consider it all joy, my brethren, when you encounter various trials, knowing that the testing of your faith produces endurance. And let endurance have its perfect result, so that you may be perfect and complete, lacking in nothing (James 1:2-4).” Suffering is not fun. No one loves correction when it happens, but trial by fire has the potential to produce exponential growth.

  • Only God Knows

There are unquestionably other reasons that God has chosen to allow evil and suffering to exist. The vastness of His knowledge are incomprehensible to finite humans. This is where faith comes in. Faith is not blind. It is not brainless. Faith simply acknowledges personal limitations and places trust in a higher power – namely God. (Side note: everyone puts faith in something, be it their own reasoning ability, popular opinion, expert recommendations, epistemological processes, etc. Faith is not exclusive to God’s people.)

Two Possibilities

So, it’s pretty clear that the Problem of Evil is not logical. In fact, it shows us that God must exist. But there is still more of the discussion to be had. Consider the outplay of each possible reality – one in which God does not exist and one in which God does exist (specifically the God of the Bible).

Imagine if the world was truly Godless. All of the suffering that we experience doesn’t go away. But what does that leave us with? If there is no God, there is no objective right and wrong. That means we don’t even have the satisfaction of calling rape, murder, adultery, lying, etc. “wrong.” We can say that we don’t like it. We can say that it causes damage to people, but there is no objective right or wrong without God (Again read Can You Be Good Without God to grasp this concept). Not only can we not call evil objectively wrong, but there is no justice for it either – save for the inconsistent justice that we experience on earth. That means that if someone gets away with murder, that’s it… no justice. Furthermore, there is no purpose for the suffering and no hope beyond the suffering. As Provine pointed out, a world without God is meaningless. That means that the suffering is meaningless as well. But suffering is not just pointless, there is also no hope beyond the suffering (without God). You live. You suffer. You die. This may seem callous to those of us who live fairly pleasurable lives, but what do you tell the person who is born in absolute poverty, who grows up in an abusive home, or who is sold into slavery at birth? They don’t enjoy the pleasures that many of us are afforded. If there is no life beyond this life, then that is all people get. No hope. No justice. No purpose.

Consider the alternative. Suffering still exists. Evil still exists. However, in this reality God exists. God is not only a just Judge, He is a merciful forgiver. That means that you not only get justice for the evils done against you, but you also have access to forgiveness for the evils that you commit. There is an eternal hope. Paul, a man who experienced parts of heaven, who was beaten to the point of death countless times tells us “I consider that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed to us.” All of the pain that we suffer (and Paul had suffered A LOT!) is NOTHING compared to the beauty that awaits us. Paul is explaining to the Corinthians how he is able to experience beating after beating, disappointment after disappointment. He knows what is coming and it’s all worth it!

One Final Point To Be Made

It’s often said that time heals all wounds. Of course, this is not fully true, but there is truth within the phrase. In my teens I was suicidal, addicted to drugs, and depressed for an extended period of time. In only a decade those things feel like a distant reality, if not a different life altogether. At the time, those pains seemed insurmountable. If time heals all wounds, can you imagine what healing will come in the span of eternity and in the presence of God? It is no wonder that Paul said what he said.

Conclusion

So what have we learned?

The “Problem of Evil” is really no problem at all – at least not for theists. Both premise three and premise four not only fail, but they actually make belief in God both rational and beneficial. As followers of Christ, we can rest assured that evil is real, but it has been defeated. With God there is justice for evil, forgiveness from evil, purpose in evil, hope beyond evil, and an eternity of beauty and healing awaiting us in the presence of our beloved Creator. 

WHAT DO YOU THINK? What other reasons might God have for allowing evil? Leave a comment below and share to get your friends in on the conversation.

Subscribe to this blog (on the right) to get updates and to receive exclusive content from Redeemed Royalty Ministries, Chris, and The Daily Rebuke!

For more like this, check out the rest of the book:Prove It: The Art & Science of Understanding & Articulating Why You Believe What You Believe


IF YOU HAVE FURTHER QUESTIONS, DON’T HESITATE TO REACH OUT TO ME AT REDEEMEDROYALTY.ORG, @CHRIS_EKKLESIA ON TWITTER, OR ON MY PERSONAL FACEBOOK PAGE OR THE MINISTRY FACEBOOK PAGE!

3 Comments
  • dgaskins08
    Posted at 23:57h, 27 June Reply

    I tend to think that a reply to premise three concerning suffering, not moral evil, can be developed around the idea that we have a terrible perception of suffering. We see death and pain as “evil” when truly it is not. We look at death with fear when we should not. We look at suffering with devastation when we should look at it as another tool to love. We look at sadness as detrimental when we should use it to show contentment. This actually goes along with you point about Job, but my main point is that we have a ridiculous perspective of trials. If we looked at trials as the great opportunities that they truly are, then we wouldn’t consider it so evil for them to exist.

    Enjoyed this greatly.

  • Deanna
    Posted at 09:09h, 29 June Reply

    Great read. Very interesting perspective. I agree that sometimes our hard times are to remind us that without God there is not much hope. Especially when your going through something and you can’t see a way out. With God there always seems like a way out. There is always Hope!
    Thanks you!

    • admin
      Posted at 09:12h, 29 June Reply

      Absolutely Deanna. Suffering can be very difficult. This understanding has helped me tremendously. Don’t know where I’d be without it!

Leave a Reply

We only ship to the continental United States